Last year’s off-season was filled with player movement. Atlanta signing Jamal Crawford, Ron Artest switching teams with Trevor Ariza, Washington adding Mike Miller and Randy Foye, and of course Shaq moving to Cleveland were all considered huge upgrades for each team. Now that the season is over it’s time to take a look at some of these changes and assess the value each team received from their new players. For each graph I used Win Shares and compared it to each player’s salary for last year. I only included players who were traded or signed last summer before the season began, and spent the entire season with their new teams. I also had to leave off a few players who basically played zero minutes for their new teams. The first table is the Top 10 in terms of Win Shares produced for their new teams.
Player |
Team |
Win Shares |
’09-’10 Salary |
$ per Win Share |
Zack Randolph |
MEM |
9.7 |
16,000,000.00 |
1,649,484.54 |
Vince Carter |
ORL |
7.4 |
16,000,000.00 |
2,162,162.16 |
Jamal Crawford |
ATL |
7.3 |
9,360,000.00 |
1,282,191.78 |
Andre Miller |
POR |
7.0 |
6,730,800.00 |
961,542.86 |
Channing Frye |
PHO |
6.4 |
2,000,000.00 |
312,500.00 |
Richard Jefferson |
SAS |
6.0 |
14,200,000.00 |
2,366,666.67 |
Matt Barnes |
ORL |
5.9 |
1,600,000.00 |
271,186.44 |
Quentin Richardson |
MIA |
5.8 |
9,352,400.00 |
1,612,482.76 |
Ersan Ilyasova |
MIL |
5.8 |
2,100,000.00 |
362,068.97 |
Emeka Okafor |
NOR |
5.5 |
10,538,937.00 |
1,916,170.36 |
Not many surprises with this list. It does emphasize the incredible contributions made by Zack Randolph this year. The next table shows the Top 10 in terms of Win Shares produced per dollars spent in salary. These are the players who produced the most, for the least amount of money; essentially the players who provided the most value.
Player |
Team |
Win Shares |
’09-’10 Salary |
$ per Win Share |
Arron Afflalo |
DEN |
4.2 |
1,086,240.00 |
258,628.57 |
Matt Barnes |
ORL |
5.9 |
1,600,000.00 |
271,186.44 |
Jason Williams |
ORL |
4.5 |
1,306,455.00 |
290,323.33 |
Carlos Arroyo |
MIA |
3.7 |
1,107,572.00 |
299,343.78 |
Channing Frye |
PHO |
6.4 |
2,000,000.00 |
312,500.00 |
Ersan Ilyasova |
MIL |
5.8 |
2,100,000.00 |
362,068.97 |
Keith Bogans |
SAS |
2.6 |
1,033,342.00 |
397,439.23 |
Courtney Lee |
NJN |
3.1 |
1,264,440.00 |
407,883.87 |
Shelden Williams |
BOS |
2.0 |
825,497.00 |
412,748.50 |
Ryan Anderson |
ORL |
3.1 |
1,317,120.00 |
424,877.42 |
Here, some surprises start to show up. Orlando comes out looking great. The huge amount they paid for production from Vince Carter and non-production from Brandon Bass, is off-set by the incredibly cheap production they received from Barnes, Anderson and Williams. I haven’t heard his name mentioned, and he will ultimately be judged by how the team (and Carter) performs in the playoffs, but Otis Smith, Executive of the Year? They will miss Courtney Lee in a few years though. He produced a fourth of New Jersey’s 12 wins this year for an extremely reasonable price. Denver looks great for letting Dahntay Jones walk and finding a cheaper more effective replacement in Arron Afflalo. This is also a great representation of what an important signing Channing Frye was for Phoenix. Now, the flip side of the coin. Here are the Top 10 players in terms of most dollars spent per Win Share produced. These are the players whose production was the most expensive, the players who provided the least value to their teams. I left off Stephen Hunter, Malik Allen, Reggie Evans, Chris Wilcox and Jarron Collins, because they played so few minutes that the numbers were extremely skewed.
Player |
Team |
Win Shares |
’09-’10 Salary |
$ per Win Share |
Shaquille O’Neal |
CLE |
2.1 |
20,000,000.00 |
9,523,809.52 |
Marcus Williams |
MEM |
0.1 |
855,189.00 |
8,551,890.00 |
Ben Gordon |
DET |
2.1 |
10,000,000.00 |
4,761,904.76 |
Kevin Ollie |
OKC |
0.3 |
1,306,455.00 |
4,354,850.00 |
Tyson Chandler |
CHA |
2.9 |
11,850,000.00 |
4,086,206.90 |
Darius Songaila |
NOR |
1.3 |
4,526,000.00 |
3,481,538.46 |
Ramon Sessions |
MIN |
1.1 |
3,670,667.00 |
3,336,970.00 |
Fabricio Oberto |
WAS |
0.6 |
1,800,000.00 |
3,000,000.00 |
Sean May |
SAC |
0.3 |
884,881.00 |
2,949,603.33 |
Hedo Turkoglu |
TOR |
3.4 |
9,000,000.00 |
2,647,058.82 |
Again, not many surprises here. The acquisitions of Chandler, Turkoglu and Gordon have been viewed as flops most of the season. In Gordon’s case before the season even started. I understand that some of these players provide value beyond what shows up in the Win Share statistic. O’Neal was brought in by Cleveland mostly to offer an additional post presence to combat Dwight Howard and the Magic in the playoffs. If they win the title, getting any sort of contribution from Shaq, I guarantee everyone in Cleveland will recognize that it was worth every dollar. However, the lack of value from some less heralded additions such as Oberto and Sessions is pretty striking.
With so many top tier free agents and so much cap space, this is sure to be a wild summer. My only advice would be “Buyer Beware“. There are some game changing values available, but just as many bank-breaking lemons. To satisfy curiousity, I included the entire list of acquisitions from last summer below.
A few minutes after posting I noticed this post on The Baseline about acquisitions from last summer making big impacts in the playoffs. They mentioned Grant Hill and Glen Davis who aren’t included on my list because they both re-signed with their previous teams. They also pointed out Jamario Moon and Andre Miller. Both players are produced a decent quantity of Win Shares this season, each at less then $1 million per. I went back in and bolded their names on my big list.
Detroit fans – Examine at your own risk!
Player |
Team |
Win Shares |
09-10 Salary |
$ per WS |
Jamal Crawford |
ATL |
7.3 |
9,360,000.00 |
1,282,191.78 |
Joe Smith |
ATL |
0.9 |
1,306,455.00 |
1,451,616.67 |
Marquis Daniels |
BOS |
1.3 |
1,990,000.00 |
1,530,769.23 |
Rasheed Wallace |
BOS |
3.6 |
5,584,000.00 |
1,551,111.11 |
Shelden Williams |
BOS |
2.0 |
825,497.00 |
412,748.50 |
Stephen Graham |
CHA |
1.6 |
884,881.00 |
553,050.63 |
Tyson Chandler |
CHA |
2.9 |
11,850,000.00 |
4,086,206.90 |
Jannero Pargo |
CHI |
-0.3 |
2,000,000.00 |
-6,666,666.67 |
Anthony Parker |
CLE |
4.9 |
2,644,320.00 |
539,657.14 |
Jamario Moon |
CLE |
2.9 |
2,750,000.00 |
948,275.86 |
Leon Powe |
CLE |
0.5 |
855,189.00 |
1,710,378.00 |
Shaquille O’Neal |
CLE |
2.1 |
20,000,000.00 |
9,523,809.52 |
Tim Thomas |
DAL |
0.7 |
1,306,455.00 |
1,866,364.29 |
Arron Afflalo |
DEN |
4.2 |
1,086,240.00 |
258,628.57 |
Joey Graham |
DEN |
1.1 |
884,881.00 |
804,437.27 |
Malik Allen |
DEN |
0.1 |
1,300,000.00 |
13,000,000.00 |
Ben Gordon |
DET |
2.1 |
10,000,000.00 |
4,761,904.76 |
Charlie Villanueva |
DET |
3.5 |
6,500,000.00 |
1,857,142.86 |
Chris Wilcox |
DET |
0.2 |
3,000,000.00 |
15,000,000.00 |
Devean George |
GSW |
1.3 |
1,600,000.00 |
1,230,769.23 |
Mikki Moore |
GSW |
0.6 |
537,952.00 |
896,586.67 |
David Anderson |
HOU |
1.3 |
2,300,000.00 |
1,769,230.77 |
Trevor Ariza |
HOU |
3.2 |
5,854,000.00 |
1,829,375.00 |
Dahntay Jones |
IND |
1.8 |
2,500,000.00 |
1,388,888.89 |
Earl Watson |
IND |
2.6 |
2,800,000.00 |
1,076,923.08 |
Luther Head |
IND |
0.6 |
884,881.00 |
1,474,801.67 |
Solomon Jones |
IND |
0.8 |
1,620,000.00 |
2,025,000.00 |
Rasual Butler |
LAC |
2.7 |
3,945,000.00 |
1,461,111.11 |
Ron Artest |
LAL |
5.3 |
5,854,000.00 |
1,104,528.30 |
Jamal Tinsley |
MEM |
-0.3 |
990,300.00 |
-3,301,000.00 |
Marcus Williams |
MEM |
0.1 |
855,189.00 |
8,551,890.00 |
Stephen Hunter |
MEM |
0.1 |
3,696,000.00 |
36,960,000.00 |
Zack Randolph |
MEM |
9.7 |
16,000,000.00 |
1,649,484.54 |
Carlos Arroyo |
MIA |
3.7 |
1,107,572.00 |
299,343.78 |
Quentin Richardson |
MIA |
5.8 |
9,352,400.00 |
1,612,482.76 |
Carlos Delfino |
MIL |
4.8 |
3,500,000.00 |
729,166.67 |
Ersan Ilyasova |
MIL |
5.8 |
2,100,000.00 |
362,068.97 |
Kurt Thomas |
MIL |
2.1 |
3,800,000.00 |
1,809,523.81 |
Ramon Sessions |
MIN |
1.1 |
3,670,667.00 |
3,336,970.00 |
Ryan Hollins |
MIN |
1.2 |
2,183,333.00 |
1,819,444.17 |
Sasha Pavlovic |
MIN |
-1.2 |
1,500,000.00 |
-1,250,000.00 |
Courtney Lee |
NJN |
3.1 |
1,264,440.00 |
407,883.87 |
Darius Songaila |
NOR |
1.3 |
4,526,000.00 |
3,481,538.46 |
Emeka Okafor |
NOR |
5.5 |
10,538,937.00 |
1,916,170.36 |
Kevin Ollie |
OKC |
0.3 |
1,306,455.00 |
4,354,850.00 |
Brandon Bass |
ORL |
2.0 |
4,000,000.00 |
2,000,000.00 |
Jason Williams |
ORL |
4.5 |
1,306,455.00 |
290,323.33 |
Matt Barnes |
ORL |
5.9 |
1,600,000.00 |
271,186.44 |
Ryan Anderson |
ORL |
3.1 |
1,317,120.00 |
424,877.42 |
Vince Carter |
ORL |
7.4 |
16,000,000.00 |
2,162,162.16 |
Rodney Carney |
PHI |
0.6 |
855,189.00 |
1,425,315.00 |
Channing Frye |
PHO |
6.4 |
2,000,000.00 |
312,500.00 |
Jarron Collins |
PHO |
0.1 |
1,181,803.00 |
11,818,030.00 |
Andre Miller |
POR |
7.0 |
6,730,800.00 |
961,542.86 |
Juwan Howard |
POR |
2.6 |
1,306,455.00 |
502,482.69 |
Ime Udoka |
SAC |
0.8 |
838,034.00 |
1,047,542.50 |
Sean May |
SAC |
0.3 |
884,881.00 |
2,949,603.33 |
Keith Bogans |
SAS |
2.6 |
1,033,342.00 |
397,439.23 |
Richard Jefferson |
SAS |
6.0 |
14,200,000.00 |
2,366,666.67 |
Amir Johnson |
TOR |
4.5 |
3,666,666.00 |
814,814.67 |
Hedo Turkoglu |
TOR |
3.4 |
9,000,000.00 |
2,647,058.82 |
Jarrett Jack |
TOR |
4.8 |
4,500,000.00 |
937,500.00 |
Rasho Nesterovic |
TOR |
0.8 |
1,990,000.00 |
2,487,500.00 |
Reggie Evans |
TOR |
0.2 |
4,960,000.00 |
24,800,000.00 |
Sonny Weems |
TOR |
1.3 |
736,420.00 |
566,476.92 |
Fabricio Oberto |
WAS |
0.6 |
1,800,000.00 |
3,000,000.00 |
Mike Miller |
WAS |
3.9 |
9,750,000.00 |
2,500,000.00 |
Randy Foye |
WAS |
2.2 |
3,575,761.00 |
1,625,345.91 |